Yearly Archive: 2016

Every two years, members of the Judicial Performance Evaluation Committees review the work of non-partisan judges up for retention. In this archive, you will find evaluation information and the committees’ recommendations for judges who were on the retention ballot in Missouri in 2016.

Richard B. Teitelman

Richard B. Teitelman

100% of the Committee voted Judge Teitelman substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

James M. Dowd

James M. Dowd

100% of the Committee voted Judge Dowd substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Philip M. Hess

Philip M. Hess

100% of the Committee voted Judge Hess substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Shane T. Alexander

Shane T. Alexander

100% of the Committee voted Judge Alexander substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Louis Angles

Louis Angles

100% of the Committee voted Judge Angles substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

K. Elizabeth Davis

K. Elizabeth Davis

100% of the Committee voted Judge Davis substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Richard B. Teitelman

Richard B. Teitelman

100% of the Committee voted Judge Teitelman substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Jason R. Brown

Jason R. Brown

100% of the Committee voted Judge Brown substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Ron Carrier

Ron Carrier

100% of the Committee voted Judge Carrier substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Douglas A. Hosmer

Douglas A. Hosmer

100% of the Committee voted Judge Hosmer substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Richard B. Teitelman

Richard B. Teitelman

100% of the Committee voted Judge Teitelman substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

S. Margene Burnett

S. Margene Burnett

100% of the Committee voted Judge Burnett substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

David M. Byrn

David M. Byrn

100% of the Committee voted Judge Byrn substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Joel P. Fahnestock

Joel P. Fahnestock

100% of the Committee Voted Judge Fahnestock substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Jeffrey C. Keal

Jeffrey C. Keal

100% of the Committee voted Judge Keal substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Sandra C. Midkiff

Sandra C. Midkiff

100% of the Committee voted Judge Midkiff substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Jalilah Otto

Jalilah Otto

100% of the Committee voted Judge Otto substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Jennifer M. Phillips

Jennifer M. Phillips

100% of the Committee voted Judge Phillips substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

W. Brent Powell

W. Brent Powell

100% of the Committee voted Judge Powell substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Janette K. Rodecap

Janette K. Rodecap

100% of the Committee voted Judge Rodecap substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Bryan E. Round

Bryan E. Round

95% of the Committee voted Judge Round substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

20 Committee members voted “MEETS”
1 Committee member voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Richard B. Teitelman

Richard B. Teitelman

100% of the Committee voted Judge Teitelman substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Robert L. Trout

Robert L. Trout

100% of the Committee voted Judge Trout substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

J. Dale Youngs

J. Dale Youngs

100% of the Committee voted Judge Youngs substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Dennis C. Eckold

Dennis C. Eckold

100% of the Committee voted Judge Eckold substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Thomas C. Fincham

Thomas C. Fincham

100% of the Committee voted Judge Fincham substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

W. Ann Hansbrough

W. Ann Hansbrough

100% of the Committee voted Judge Hansbrough substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Abe Quint Shafer

Abe Quint Shafer

100% of the Committee voted Judge Shafer substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Richard B. Teitelman

Richard B. Teitelman

100% of the Committee voted Judge Teitelman substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Thomas C. Clark, III

Thomas C. Clark, III

100% of the Committee voted Judge Clark substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Nicole Colbert-Botchway

Nicole Colbert-Botchway

100% of the Committee voted Judge Colbert-Botchway substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

James M. Dowd

James M. Dowd

100% of the Committee voted Judge Dowd substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Thomas J. Frawley

Thomas J. Frawley

100% of the Committee voted Judge Frawley substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Philip D. Heagney

Philip D. Heagney

100% of the Committee voted Judge Heagney substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Philip M. Hess

Philip M. Hess

100% of the Committee voted Judge Hess substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Bryan L. Hettenbach

Bryan L. Hettenbach

100% of the Committee voted Judge Hettenbach substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

David C. Mason

David C. Mason

100% of the Committee voted Judge Mason substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Christopher E. McGraugh

Christopher E. McGraugh

100% of the Committee voted Judge McGraugh substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Michael K. Mullen

Michael K. Mullen

100% of the Committee voted Judge Mullen substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Mark H. Neill

Mark H. Neill

100% of the Committee voted Judge Neill substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Dennis M. Schaumann

Dennis M. Schaumann

100% of the Committee voted Judge Schaumann substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Calea Stovall-Reid

Calea Stovall-Reid

100% of the Committee voted Judge Stovall-Reid substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

James E. Sullivan

James E. Sullivan

100% of the Committee voted Judge Sullivan substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Richard B. Teitelman

Richard B. Teitelman

100% of the Committee voted Judge Teitelman substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Robin Ransom Vannoy

Robin Ransom Vannoy

100% of the Committee voted Judge Vannoy substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

John N. Borbonus

John N. Borbonus

100% of the Committee voted Judge Borbonus substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

James M. Dowd

James M. Dowd

100% of the Committee voted Judge Dowd substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

John R. Essner

John R. Essner

100% of the Committee voted Judge Essner substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Sandra Farragut-Hemphill

Sandra Farragut-Hemphill

100% of the Committee voted Judge Farragut-Hemphill substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Robert M. Heggie

Robert M. Heggie

100% of the Committee voted Judge Heggie substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Philip M. Hess

Philip M. Hess

100% of the Committee voted Judge Hess substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Dale W. Hood

Dale W. Hood

5% of the Committee voted Judge Hood substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

1 Committee member voted “MEETS”
20 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Gloria Clark Reno

Gloria Clark Reno

95% of the Committee voted Judge Reno substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

20 Committee members voted “MEETS”
1 Committee member voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Mary Bruntrager Schroeder

Mary Bruntrager Schroeder

81% of the Committee voted Judge Schroeder substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

17 Committee members voted “MEETS”
4 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Ellen Levy Siwak

Ellen Levy Siwak

95% of the Committee voted Judge Siwak substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

20 Committee members voted “MEETS”
1 Committee member voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Richard B. Teitelman

Richard B. Teitelman

100% of the Committee voted Judge Teitelman substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Barbara W. Wallace

Barbara W. Wallace

100% of the Committee voted Judge Wallace substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Carolyn C. Whittington

Carolyn C. Whittington

100% of the Committee voted Judge Whittington substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

James M. Dowd

James M. Dowd

100% of the Committee voted Judge Dowd substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Philip M. Hess

Philip M. Hess

100% of the Committee voted Judge Hess substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”

Richard B. Teitelman

Richard B. Teitelman

100% of the Committee voted Judge Teitelman substantially MEETS overall judicial performance standards.

21 Committee members voted “MEETS”
0 Committee members voted “DOES NOT MEET”